Women of #nzpol Twitter: on weight, food and pregnancy

The “Women of #nzpol Twitter roundup” is brought to you in the interests of amplifying women’s voices in the political debate and also because:

sansa misandry

I got the inside running on this one by catching five minutes of Breakfast on One’s interview with John Key:

The rest of the media weren’t far behind.

I just want to note the first sentence of the article Andrea Vance linked to:

More than 60 per cent of pregnant women gain more weight than is recommended, which has implications for a child’s weight later in life.

Not implications for health; implications for weight. We’re so wedded to the notion that being fat automatically means you’re unhealthy that we don’t even need to establish whether or not weight gain in pregnancy leads to health issues. It just must because ew, fatties.

Take it away, Twitter:


And back to me:


For many, many informed perspectives on what happens when you force fat people to go to the doctor, check out First Do No Harm.

This is a common tune for me, but I’m just going to repeat it: fatness does not equal poor health. Thinness does not equal good health. Correlating certain diseases with fatness does not mean fatness causes those diseases. Considering the incredibly fatphobic society we live in, it’s ludicrous not to consider the effects of stress, deprivation, and societally-applauded yo-yo dieting on the overall health of fat people, even IF fat people were inherently less healthy than thin people, which they’re not.

And when it comes to policing the every waking thought and action of pregnant people – including how much weight they gain during pregnancy – there really aren’t good grounds to be talking about “evidence-based approaches”.

Stop talking about weight. Stop judging people based on their weight. Stop buying into the weightloss industry’s propaganda. Because if you want to know the #1 reason why we’re not having national conversations about food access, living wages, family time, and health awareness? Maybe it’s something to do with the fact we keep saying it’s all fat people’s fault for not being able to put down the doughnuts.

And for god’s sake stop making pregnant people responsible for the welfare of our entire society.

Pointless negativity and the left

This is a slightly whingey post about how much we whinge, so let me state right up front that I can spot my own irony!

There’s a lot to get us down as progressive/lefty folk. The dominance capitalism feels insurmountable, we’re insulted at every turn for not getting with the cool neoliberal programme (or “learning math”) or sneered at to stop making such a bloody fuss.

It’s only natural that we will, now and then, throw up their hands and cry “this is all just useless, why do we bother?” It’s probably even natural – though often it’s also self-gratifying – to lament “why don’t people understand? Why do they keep electing these bastards?”

community why
And I don’t want to say “shut up, everyone, quit whinging.” Venting is great. It stops you exploding. We bond by being a sympathetic ear for each other when it all just seems hopeless.  And there’s plenty to critique our opponents for – we cannot accept their framing that the very act of opposition is “just being negative for no good reason”.

What I want – if I may make a tiny plea which everyone’s welcome to take or leave as they see fit – is for us to remember that yep, the task is difficult. The road is long. We’re all going to get really, really angry about it, many many times, on the way. But let’s bear in mind that we’re all meat popsicles, and we all have a limited amount of energy, and none of us can thrive and keep up the good fight if the only thing we ever hear is negativity, even from our own side.

fifth element meat popsicle

Specifically, this means that, dear comrades, we don’t have to add a nasty little comment on every single blog post or tweet or Facebook status update we see. We don’t have to snark “Not bloody likely, everyone loves John Key because they’re sheeple!!!!!” every time someone says “here’s a great new idea about how we change the government in 2017.”

(We definitely need to never, ever use the phrases “sheeple” or “sleepy hobbits” ever again.)

Maybe this is just something I notice because I spend a lot of time on blogs and social media. But it feels like every time someone says “here’s an interesting article. What do you reckon?” or “here’s my latest cool idea. What do you think?” the first comment is inevitably, “IT’S POINTLESS BECAUSE WE’RE ALL DOOOOOOOOOOOOOMED AND THE SHEEPLE ARE STUUUUUUUUUUPID.”

And there’s only one situation in which it’s acceptable to use the word “doomed”.


Find the place for ranting. Vent when you need to. But remember that we’re a community. And our experiences and attitudes are heavily impacted by the statements and images we see. When you’re screaming “John Key is destroying our country and there’s no hope”, you’re reinforcing, for everyone who reads it, that there is no hope. Who’s going to turn out to vote when there’s no hope? What do we campaign for if there’s no solution?

The other side want us demoralized and uninspired. They want us so focused on tearing each other down that we don’t organise to defeat them. Let’s stay angry – but stop playing their game.


Statement of the damn obvious: there’s a difference between pointless negativity and genuine disagreement. There’s a difference between pointless negativity and justified outrage. You can probably figure out which one I’m talking about.